Ring in the New Year

Making Changes in 2025

Shop Sustainably

New Beginnings - New Habits - Sustainability

2025 Holds Great Promise

$5 & Below Collection

3359 products
    Our collection of items that can be had for $5 and Below recieves the same care and attention as all other consignment categories.  Clothes are laundered and all hard surfaces are cleaned.  You might see slight imperfections but we deemed them minor enough to be forgiven.  
    3359 products
    Bride Plush Toy Set
    IttyBittys
    Velcro Leather MaryJane
    Stride Rite
    Slip On Jelly Shoes
    Wonder Nation
    Soft Sole Slip On Shoes
    Child of Mine
    Sequin Soft-Soled Boots
    OOLABE
    Velcro Tennis Shoes
    Wonder Nation
    Rattle Lion
    Baby Gund
    Sale
    McKenna
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Saige
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Really Truly Ruthie
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Nicki
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Meet Kirsten
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Aloha, Kanani
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Lanie
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Meet Rebecca
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Meet Addy
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Meet Kaya
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Julie's Journey
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Julie Tells Her Story
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Meet Julie
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Pepper's Boredom Busters
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    Praline's Book of Friendship Questions
    American Girl
    Save $3.95
    Sale
    "Riding" Doll Set
    Our Generation
    Save $5.99
    Sale
    Scrub Set Doll Clothes
    Our Generation
    Save $5.99
    Sequin Dog
    TY
    I Ruff You
    Sandra Magsamen
    Chicago Baby
    Jerome Pohlen
    Poke-A-Dot! Christmas
    Melissa & Doug
    Your Baby's First Word Will Be Dada
    Jimmy Fallon
    Who Am I? Baby Farm Animals
    Little Hippo Books
    100 First Words
    Little Tiger Press
    Voices Are Not For Yelling
    Elizabeth Verdick
    Llama Llama Gives Easter Egg
    Anna Dewdney
    Llama Llama Sand & Sun
    Anna Dewdney
    Little Mouse Finger Puppet Book
    Chronicle Books
    Hippity, Hoppity Little Bunny Finger Puppet Book
    Paragon Books
    Lady Bug Finger Puppet Book
    Chronicle Books
    Baby Orca Finger Puppet Book
    Chronicle Books
    Baby Sloth Finger Puppet Book
    Chronicle Books
    Baby Yeti Finger Puppet Book
    Chronicle Books
    Recently viewed

    OOLABE Thrift is our Featured Collection

    Get Playful with Our OOLABE Thrift Collection - Perfectly Imperfect Styles at Prices that Won't Haunt Your Wallet!

    Featured Collection

    View all
    SANTA Nightgown
    Old Navy
    LS + Pants Pajamas / All Together For ..
    Old Navy
    LS Footless Thermal Onesie / Christmas Trees
    Old Navy
    LS Shirt + Pants Pajamas / Elf
    Old Navy
    LS Shirt + Pant Pajamas / Reindeer
    Old Navy
    Puff Vest
    Old Navy
    LS Shirt
    Old Navy
    Toddler Tank Tops Pack
    Wonder Nation
    Sale
    Puffy Winter Boots
    Wonder Nation
    Save $9.97
    Sale
    Soft Soled Shoe
    Old Navy
    Save $6.99
    Soft-Soled Loafer
    Old Navy
    Slip On Canvas Shoes
    Wonder Nation
    Velcro Tennis Shoes
    Old Navy
    Slip-On Floral Shoes
    Old Navy
    Velcro Slip-On Shoes
    Wonder Nation